Feeds opened 29 October 2026
Last updated 29 October 2026. Descriptions and posts below are from public feeds that day, plus one older member post in r/logodesign that is labelled as a member's brief, not as the sidebar. No subscriber counts. A year-long search for the word rules inside r/design_critiques did not return a moderator post this page can quote, so no promo cap is invented for that sub. The Feedback Weekend removals in r/web_design are written on Best subreddits for agencies and are not repeated.
The critique is the room's actual product
Someone selling a design tool walks into these subs and sees a pile of 'thoughts?' posts, and mistakes the pile for a market that wants software. Often the author wants a human to say whether the red is wrong. The comment that belongs there is the reason the red fails, on that screen, for that job. The comment that fails is a feature list with a signup link, posted under a student portfolio. You can be useful for months and never name the tool. You should not confirm a sub whose new queue is only 'rate this' if your buyer is a design manager choosing a research repository. Those are different sentences. Write the use case as the sentence the buyer types. 'The interview notes are in three docs and nobody can find the quote' is a research buyer. 'Which of these two colours' is a critique. Karmy will go looking for whichever sentence you give it. A founder asking other founders whether the product is worth building is not a critique either. That buyer is Best subreddits for SaaS founders.
r/design_critiques asks the experienced person to review
r/Design_Critiques is the same sub as r/design_critiques. The public links use the second spelling, and the description is one description. On 29 October 2026 it said the sub helps new and amateur designers improve through reviews and critiques, and it asks an experienced designer to review a submission and share constructive suggestions. That is an invitation to do the work, not an invitation to sell.
The new posts matched the invitation and also stretched it. A graphic designer job-hunting asked for honest portfolio feedback. Two posts asked people to rate a website. Another asked for beta testers of an AI workspace that turns research into projects, a résumé, and a portfolio. The portfolio is the critique the description asked for. The beta call is a recruitment post wearing a design sub. Report the beta call. Answer the portfolio with one structural note, not a tour of your product. Because no moderator post in the search set a ratio or a karma gate, the sidebar is still yours to open before you treat 'experienced designers please review' as a blank cheque.
r/UI_Design's morning was feedback requests
The public description of r/UI_Design says user interface design is about clear, accessible, visually consistent interfaces, through layout, typography, and interaction, and that the sub also covers UX and product design, including research, information architecture, interaction design, strategy, and usability. It does not print a promotion limit. None is added here.
On 29 October 2026 the new feed was people asking to be looked at. One could not choose between two colour directions on a calorie-tracking app and disliked the red. One asked what people thought of a video background on a first marketing site, and tagged the post as AI. One said they lacked UI knowledge and wanted errors found in a course-library dashboard. One asked for feedback on a company site they had been building for weeks. The calorie post is the clean version of the room: two options, one worry, a screen. The reply picks the option that keeps the number readable, says what the red is doing to the calorie figure, and stops. If they ask what you use to check contrast, name one check, including the case where a system colour is already enough and a plugin is extra. The video-background post is a first website looking for reassurance. Answer whether the video hides the offer. Do not attach your own background.
r/userexperience moves slower, and the question is a decision
The public description of r/userexperience calls it a community for professionals, enthusiasts, and anyone interested in user experience, to share knowledge, ask questions, and discuss UX. The new feed on 29 October 2026 was not a stack of fresh posts. The latest was 28 October: someone building a custom ERP asked how experienced people choose components and layouts for different modules. Before that, 23 October, a first-time website asked whether the design made sense to anyone who had not built it. Before that, a complaint about design awards, and a question about keeping a set of application icons consistent.
A mission here should expect quiet days. Quiet is not a broken watch. The ERP question is the one worth a draft, because it has a constraint: different modules, a custom product, a person who is not sure the same card fits a finance screen and a warehouse screen. Answer with one difference, such as density, and the module where a dense table is the honest interface. A 'what UI kit should I buy' reply with no module is the pitch the question did not ask for. Confirm this sub when your buyer is that practitioner. Leave it off when you needed a feedback booth and r/UI_Design was the booth.
r/graphic_design mixes the portfolio with the invoice
The public description of r/graphic_design calls it a collaborative learning community for graphic designers at any stage, focused on education, mentorship, and mutual support. On 29 October 2026 the new feed held a portfolio review from someone job-hunting in Qatar, a first sports graphic, a 25-year art director asking whether to stay, a request for ways out of creative burnout, and a freelancer about to send a first invoice who needed a way for the client to pay. That is four different buyers in one morning.
A design tool, a course, and a payments product do not share a mission because they all saw the word design. The portfolio is a critique. The invoice is a business question, closer to a freelance practice than to a colour choice. The burnout post is not a customer. If you sell software, answer the portfolio or skip the day. If you confirm the sub, write the use case so a career-crisis title does not score. The description does not state a self-promotion rule. This page will not invent one. The mutual-support line is still a poor defence for a drive-by link.
r/logodesign says to read the rules, and a member described one
The public description of r/logodesign says it is a place to discuss logos and their design, and it tells you to read the rules before posting. The rules page itself did not open for this page, so the numbered rule is not quoted as law. What did open, from 21 February 2025, was a member's post whose brief was a logo to wave at people breaking 'rule one', so they would understand the sub will not do free work for them. That is a member describing the room in February 2025, not a moderator's current text. Read the sidebar. Do not cite that post as the rule you are enforcing.
The new feed on 29 October 2026 was the work: a landscape company in Riyadh asking if a leaf on the mark was enough, an electric-bike logo, a letterform that the author worried might be read as VA instead of K. Those are critiques. Give the reading problem, or the leaf, one sentence. A generator that 'makes logos' is the free work the 2025 brief was annoyed about, whether or not that brief is still the sidebar. Do not be the person offering to remake the mark in the thread.
Leave r/figma off, and do not redo the weekend rule
The name r/figma looks like the design tool. On 29 October 2026 its public description said it is for fans of an action-figure line, and that it is not for the design program. The new posts were figures for sale and figures people had just bought. Confirming it because your product integrates with the design tool is how you collect a removal and learn nothing. There is no second public feed under that name that was the software.
r/web_design is a real design room, and it is already written up. Best subreddits for agencies records the mod-team notice that critique requests belong in Feedback Weekend threads, and that the same removal text was still being pasted in September 2026. This page does not copy that notice. If the buyer is an agency using that sub as a booth, go there. If the buyer wants a room whose ordinary purpose is the critique, the five subs above are the ones whose descriptions say so.
What a single design product costs
Prices on the pricing page, repeated here so the FAQ matches them: 10 days free, no card, then €9 a month for one mission on Starter. A component library and a research repository are two products, so they are two missions. Growth at €19 a month holds up to five. Scale at €39 a month holds up to twenty and includes MCP. You post the critique yourself. The optional account that would post it is on the karmito page, where it says the thing is not on sale yet. This page does not invent a fee, and it does not call the request form a price.
A reply to a colour choice
Shape only. Two screens, and the author prefers the one with the red and also distrusts the red. The reply chooses, and says why in one visual fact: the red sits on the number the person came to read, so the number loses. Keep the calmer direction, and move the red to the single control that means stop or delete. Then the limit. If the type size is the real problem, swapping the hue will not fix the squint. Name a contrast check only if they ask how you would verify it. No link to your kit. No offer to redesign the app in the comments.
Feeds these notes come from
- r/design_critiques portfolio request, 29 October 2026
- r/UI_Design colour question, 29 October 2026
- r/logodesign member post on free work, 21 February 2025
- Best subreddits for agencies
- Best subreddits for copywriting
- Pricing