Agencies

Which subreddits should a marketing agency use?

r/agency is where the agency is the customer. Your client's buyers are somewhere else. Mixing those two rooms is how a useful tool gets banned and the client still has no thread.

Checked 25 October 2026

Last updated 25 October 2026. What follows is from public posts by r/agency's moderator u/JakeHundley and from removal notices posted by the r/web_design mod team. No subscriber counts. No claim about a rule that was not in those posts.

Your client is not in r/agency

An agency has two different Reddit problems, and they should not share a mission. The first is selling the agency's own service, or a tool the agency itself pays for: reporting, proposals, the inbox where five clients land. The buyer of that is an agency owner, and r/agency is the room where that person asks. The second problem is showing up where a client's buyer already asked for the client's product. That buyer is not reading a thread about retainers. They are in the niche sub for the client's job. Pointing every client mission at r/agency means you will talk to other agencies all month and call it lead generation.

Karmy is one account and one mission per client. Growth holds five missions at €19 a month. Scale holds twenty at €39 a month. There is no per-client fee on top of that. Each mission has its own product, use cases, tone, and subreddits. You can send that mission's pings to that client's Slack channel. The team still posts. The agencies page on this site is the operating version of that setup. This page is only the choice of room.

What changed in r/agency in 2025

On 5 July 2025 u/JakeHundley wrote up two rule changes. Rule 6, which had been about unsolicited DMs, became 'No unsolicited DMs or asking for DMs'. The post says the posts that describe a system the author built and then end with 'DM me for details' are ending. Asking people to DM you is now inside the rule, not only sending the DM. A draft that ends with 'happy to DM the deck' is the comment this update was written to stop.

The same post says a strict no-self-promotion rule was replaced by rule 8, 'Give more than you take'. The stated intention is that someone who actually helps can also point at a free resource, a newsletter, or a podcast. He notes that many of those are lead magnets, and some are not. He then says the sub is seeing more 'market research' and feedback requests, and that the sub is not for market research, because everyone can see the post is a way to collect leads. A 'would you use a tool that...' thread is the post he is describing. Do not give that shape to Karmy as a mission.

Automod, in that same July post: people could not post if their karma inside the sub was under 3. It had been 5. He said that number means upvotes, and that your own upvote does not count. A contributor quality filter that had been lowered was going back to high. He also said the filter is a robot, and that a real question which fails it can be sent to modmail. A brand-new account with a polished case study is the account that filter was put back to catch.

The pattern banned in January 2026

On 14 January 2026 u/JakeHundley posted that rule 10, 'No astroturfing', was in force. He described it as a question that looks organic, followed days later by comments recommending a product. He wrote that rule 8 allows self-promotion to an extent, and that disingenuous promotion does not. The post says accounts in two campaigns were banned, one around a tool called Respond that was praised while a competitor called Kommo was criticised, and a suspected one around a PR tool called Folk: a post the mods had refused to approve, then the same post from another account, then comments from accounts with no history in the sub. He wrote that if you want to promote yourself you have to contribute in multiple non-promotional ways first, and that this is an immediate ban.

That is the failure mode of 'we will just have a second account agree with us'. Karmy does not post for you, and it will not take over an existing account. The draft is yours to publish from the account that has already been useful in the sub. A second account that republishes a refused post, then a few days later picks up recommendations from accounts with no history in the sub, is the Folk pattern the January post says they banned four users for. Do not build the mission around it. If a ping is a vague 'what tools do agencies use' post with no constraint, Report it. Those are the openers the comments under that mod post already recognised as bait.

r/web_design still removes the roast

Design agencies wander into r/web_design because the work is visible there. The mod team has a removal notice they were still pasting in September 2026. On 11 September 2026 and again on 17 September 2026, u/web_design-ModTeam removed posts with the same text: requests for critiques or feedback are not allowed outside Feedback Weekend threads. Questions or requests for assistance are generally allowed if they follow the other rules. If a link is not necessary to answer the question, the post can be removed. A Tuesday thread titled 'roast this homepage' is the thing they remove. A specific question about a workflow, with no spare link, is the shape the notice says they allow.

So a design shop does not use r/web_design as a feedback booth for client work, and does not drop the studio URL under a critique they were not supposed to ask for. The useful threads are the ones where a designer is stuck on a decision and asked for a method. Answer the decision. The studio name is a profile fact, not the first sentence. Rooms whose ordinary purpose is the critique, rather than a weekend exception, are Best subreddits for design feedback.

What to confirm in the mission

If you sell software to agencies, confirm r/agency and write the use cases as an owner would type them: a retainer that slipped, a report nobody opened, a handoff between two people on the same account. If you sell nothing to agencies and you run Reddit for clients, do not confirm r/agency on the client missions. Confirm the subs where that client's buyer asks. The free Reddit report takes one website and shows threads for that domain. Use it on the prospect before you promise a sub you have not read.

A reply shape, not a posted comment. Thread: an owner says five content calendars have collapsed into one Slack argument, and asks how other shops separate them. The reply describes one shared board per client, one owner for the week, and the rule that a second person does not edit the live week. Then the limit: a tool does not fix two people who both think they are the owner. No DM, no 'we built this for agencies', no link to a booking page. If they ask what software holds the board, name one, and name the shop size where a spreadsheet is still the right answer.

Posts these notes come from

Keep going

Best subredditsBest subreddits for affiliate marketingBest subreddits for SaaS foundersFor agenciesReddit lead generation for agenciesBest subreddits for consultingBest subreddits for design feedbackPricing

Questions people ask

Should every client mission include r/agency?

No. r/agency is where agency owners talk to each other. A client's buyers are in that client's niche. One mission per client, pointed at those buyers.

Can I ask people in r/agency to DM me?

The 5 July 2025 moderator post says no. Rule 6 covers unsolicited DMs and posts that ask for a DM. Selling in private messages is the thing that update names.

What does Karmy cost for several clients?

Growth is €19 a month for up to five missions. Scale is €39 a month for up to twenty. There is no extra per-client fee. The trial is 10 days, no card.

Can I ask r/web_design to roast a homepage?

Not outside Feedback Weekend. The mod team was still removing those requests on 11 and 17 September 2026. A specific assistance question is the shape their notice allows.

Get the thread, not another tab.

Karmy watches the subreddits that match your product, scores the thread by intent, and sends a draft to Telegram. Free for 10 days, no card. One mission is €9 a month after that.

Join the waitlist →