What their own docs say the product does
ReddGrow's app guide describes four pieces. A campaign holds the product, the tone and the AI settings. They discover and score subreddits. A scanner writes drafts on active posts. A Chrome extension posts the drafts you approved, from the Reddit session already open in that browser. Their pricing FAQ is explicit that you need a Reddit account, that comments go out through that account, and that they do not post without your review.
The extension page goes further into the plumbing, and it is worth knowing before you compare "automation." Approved drafts sit in a queue. The extension runs a posting session, joins the subreddit if it has to, scrolls, types with delays, submits, and marks the draft posted. Their docs say there is a gap of at least five minutes between submissions, a session cap of 15 minutes, and one session a day. It also reads the inbox once a day so ban mail and removals can be classified. If Chrome is closed, or Reddit logs you out, posting waits.
That is a real workflow. It is also a browser you have to keep healthy. Karmy took the other road. The human posts. The product's job is to make sure the human is looking at the right thread, with words that already sound like a person and already respect the sidebar. No unpacked extension, no second Chrome profile per account, no "did the session run today" check. The cost of that choice is obvious: someone still has to paste.
Price, from their plan cards and FAQ
The pricing page opens with "plans from $99/month" and a 14-day trial. They charge the card you saved when the trial ends, unless you cancel under Settings, then Billing. Cancel anytime, no fee, no prorated refund for a partial month. Unlimited seats on the paid plans, according to both the cards and the help center.
| Plan | Monthly | Yearly rate | What their FAQ spells out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Starter | $99 | $79/mo ($948/yr) | 1 Reddit account, 1 campaign, 10 subreddits, 1 brand-monitor domain, 2 AI answer pages a week |
| Growth | $199 | $159/mo ($1,908/yr) | 3 Reddit accounts, 3 campaigns, 30 subreddits. Help center says Slack unlocks here. |
| Pro | $399 | $319/mo ($3,828/yr) | Unlimited Reddit accounts, 3 campaigns, 100 subreddits, 5 domains, 4 AI answer pages a week, Slack listed, priority support |
They also list Agency and Enterprise without a public number on the card we read, so those stay unnamed here. The help center lists paid add-ons (extra drafts per day, an extra campaign, an extra monitored domain, extra prompts). Their separate docs page describes limits differently, including a different account count on Growth, so we are not mixing that table in. If you are about to pay, open the live pricing page. We are not your invoice.
Karmy after the trial: Ten days free, no card to start. Then Starter is €9 a month for one mission, Growth is €19 a month for up to five missions, and Scale is €39 a month for up to 20 missions. Cancel from Telegram. Growth adds post ideas you can publish and a webhook. Scale adds MCP, competitor-thread watch, and the weekly AI check. A karmito is coming soon: a Reddit account Karmy runs for you. The Telegram bot, the webhook and the MCP still do not post to Reddit.
Warmup is the part people skip, and they did not
ReddGrow's karma warmup docs are specific. At the bottom of the karma range, drafts are not allowed to mention the product, the brand or the site. As karma climbs, a larger share of drafts may be promotional. They show a warmup widget counted in days, with phases that start lighter than full pace, and they tell you not to drop promotional posts by hand in the target subs during the first seven days. Subreddits unlock against a karma threshold they configured when they discovered the community.
We agree with the instinct and we will not pretend our public pages describe the same machinery. If you post yourself, follow the 30-day warm-up: comments, then text posts, links late, promotion rare. A shadowban makes the whole week imaginary. We do have a shadowban checker, the logged-out check, next to the written guide. A karmito is coming soon. The draft in Telegram is the product you get without it.
AI visibility is a quota over there, a weekly Scale check over here
ReddGrow's pricing is organized around getting named by ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI. Prompt quotas are published twice, and the two pages do not match. Their pricing FAQ lists 50 on Starter, 200 on Growth and 300 on Pro. Their help center lists 10, 100 and 200 for those same plans. We are not picking a winner, and we are not repeating their multiplier claims ("about 2x", "about 5x", "68%"). They also talk about AI answer pages per week.
Karmy does not sell a prompt pack. On Scale, a weekly check of ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini. You should still ask the question yourself. A vendor's dashboard is a convenience. The assistant's answer box is the fact. The weekly routine for Perplexity, Gemini and other AI answers is the AI answers playbook. It does not promise a ChatGPT citation from Reddit. That drop, 3.83% to 0.52% on 14 August 2026, is in the blog post and in the ChatGPT guide.
A Tuesday on each product
On ReddGrow, from their docs, Tuesday is a dashboard day. You look at drafts, you approve the ones that sound like you, and you trust that Chrome, logged into the right profile, will type them during its window. If you have three accounts you are on at least the Growth plan, and each account wants its own browser profile. Slack, if you are on the tier where they unlocked it, can take a digest and a one-click approval. That is attractive if several people share the queue and nobody wants to live in Reddit.
On Karmy, Tuesday is a chat. The threads that survived the intent filter are already there, with a draft. You change the one sentence that makes it yours. You open Reddit and you post. If a cofounder should see it too, Growth can mirror the opportunity to Slack or a CRM through one webhook. There is no approval queue because there is no poster sitting behind it. The failure mode is human: you ignore Telegram. The failure mode on an extension is technical: the browser slept, the cookie died, the session already ran.
We like our failure mode better for a founder who posts five times a week and wants to see the thread before it goes out. We like theirs better if the requirement is "approved comments get typed while I am in another tab," and you have read their cooldown rules so you are not expecting a burst of twenty replies at lunch.
What we will not claim
- We will not claim ReddGrow has no safety limits. Their extension docs and warmup docs are full of limits. Read them.
- We do have a shadowban checker. It is the logged-out check, published next to the written guide. It does not log into your Reddit account.
- We will not claim either tool can force an AI assistant to cite you. Presence in useful threads is the lever. The assistant decides.
- We will not quote a testimonial. If you want social proof, it has to be on the page that earned it, not borrowed.
Who should stay on ReddGrow
Stay if you want the extension, you already have Reddit accounts you are willing to connect, and you want a counted AI-prompt report plus a content studio inside one subscription. Their Starter card is built for one account and ten subreddits. That is a real starting box, at a real price, with a trial that will bill you.
Switch, or start here instead, if the dashboard is the thing you already know you will not open. Karmy is rude in a useful way. It assumes you have one job on Reddit, which is to show up in a few threads as a person, and it refuses to become a second operating system. Ten days, no card, then a price that looks like a software subscription for a solo product and not like a seat on a marketing platform.
ReddGrow alternative: FAQ
Is Karmy a ReddGrow alternative?
For discovery and drafting, yes. For the browser posting after you approve, no. That second half is their Chrome extension. Hands-free posting on Karmy is a karmito, which is coming soon.
How much does ReddGrow cost?
From their pricing page: Starter $99 a month or $79 a month billed annually, Growth $199 or $159, Pro $399 or $319. Trial is 14 days and renews. Karmy is €9, €19, or €39 a month on Scale after 10 free days. Scale covers up to 20 missions.
Do I need the Chrome extension?
On ReddGrow, yes, if you want their posting step. Their docs say the extension uses your logged-in Reddit session. On Karmy there is nothing to install. Telegram is the interface.
How does warmup compare?
ReddGrow documents a karma-based cap on how many drafts may mention the product, and a first week of lighter posting. Karmy documents a 30-day plan for accounts you run yourself, and a shadowban checker. Do not mix those schedules up.
Can a team use Karmy?
Growth covers up to five missions in one Telegram feed, and the webhook can fan a thread out to Slack or a CRM. Scale covers up to 20 missions. It is not an unlimited-seat org with roles. If you need that shape, their unlimited-seats line is the one to verify on their billing page.
Karmy