ReplyGuy alternative

ReplyGuy alternative: Reddit intent, no credits

ReplyGuy finds conversations where your keywords show up and drafts a reply that can mention the product. It speaks web-wide, prices you in credits, and tells two different stories about who hits submit on Reddit. Karmy is the stubborn version: Reddit only, intent over keyword volume, a draft in Telegram, your account, your submit button.

Join the waitlist → Free for 10 days
no card to start
Karmy
Reddit · no credit meter
✓ Threads scored by buying intent
✓ Draft in your voice, rules checked first
✓ You post from the account you already have
✓ Flat price: €9, €19, or €39 on Scale
✓ Lives in Telegram, not a mention inbox
· No Twitter, no LinkedIn, on purpose
ReplyGuy
keyword mentions · credits
✓ Keywords across the web, drafts on the hits
✓ Public plans from $49 to $499 a month
✓ Auto-replies listed; their guide says Twitter
✕ 1 credit to surface a comment, 3 to post a reply
✕ Reddit posting is described two ways on their site
✕ Keyword match is a wider net than intent

ReplyGuy facts are from replyguy.com and replyguy.com/how-it-works, read 23 October 2026. Plan numbers are the monthly column on that homepage.

What ReplyGuy says it does

The homepage is a five-step loop. You pick keywords, they suggest some. They track those keywords. An AI pass keeps posts that look recent and relevant and like a place your product "deserves a shoutout." Another pass writes a reply that is supposed to help the original poster and mention you when it fits. Then "sent." Their comparison with doing it by hand says the manual version is 15 to 30 minutes of monitoring, 15 to 30 minutes of reading, and 30 to 60 minutes of writing, per project, per day. That is their framing of the chore, not a study we ran.

The how-it-works page is less breezy, and it is the page we trust more for operations, because it names platforms. Auto-replies are currently available for Twitter. Reddit and LinkedIn are semi-manual. On Reddit you copy the draft, open the post, paste, submit, and go back to mark it published. You can also mark a mention yourself and ask for a reply. If auto-reply is off, Twitter falls back to the same manual dance.

Karmy is that manual Reddit ending, with the front of the funnel changed. We do not start from a keyword list you maintain. You describe the product, the site and the use cases once. We look for threads where the intent is narrow: a tool request, an alternative request, a competitor complaint, a job-to-be-done you actually solve. The draft arrives in Telegram. You still copy, open, paste, submit. We are not embarrassed by that. On Reddit, the person who hits submit should have read the comment.

The credit meter, copied off the pricing block

ReplyGuy says every plan is a monthly budget of credits. A high-intent comment they surface costs 1. A reply posted and verified, on any platform, costs 3. A reply sent as a DM when a comment cannot be posted costs 5. A brand audit after the first free one costs 5. Extra credits, they say, do not expire. You can cancel, pause, upgrade or downgrade from the dashboard. They also say there is a free trial.

Monthly planPriceKeywordsCreditsProjects
Pro$49101001
Business$99253005
Enterprise$1991001,000Unlimited
Agency$4991,0005,000Unlimited, plus a concierge line

The yearly toggle on the same page is labeled "5 months free." The yearly figures we could read on the public cards were Pro $349, Business $699 and Enterprise $1,399. Agency is $3,499 billed yearly. Screenshot proof of each reply shows up from Pro upward on the monthly cards. The public cards list auto-replies, notifications, reports and support.

Do the credit math on the public plans. One hundred credits on the $49 Pro plan is about 33 posted replies, or fewer if you also pay to have comments found. Karmy does not charge per thread. Ten days free, no card to start. Then Starter is €9 a month for one mission, Growth is €19 a month for up to five missions, and Scale is €39 a month for up to 20 missions. The limit is the mission count, not a wallet that drains when a keyword gets popular. A karmito is coming soon: a Reddit account Karmy runs for you. The Telegram bot, the webhook and the MCP still do not post to Reddit.

Two pages, two stories about the Reddit account

This is the part to read twice, because we will not paper over it.

ReplyGuy's how-it-works page says you publish Reddit replies yourself. Copy, open, paste, submit, mark published. Auto-reply, today, is a Twitter feature.

ReplyGuy's homepage FAQ, under "What accounts send the replies?", says something else. For Reddit: they use purchased accounts, provided by email within a few days of subscribing. For Twitter: they help you find where to reply and what to say, and you edit and post. The same FAQ says many customers report an uptick within one to two weeks. That is their wording about their customers. We are not adopting it as a result you should expect, from them or from us.

We cannot tell you which page is the current product. Both were public on the same day. If the account that speaks for your product matters to you, and it should, ask ReplyGuy which description is live before you subscribe. A purchased account you do not control is a different risk from a draft you paste into an account you warmed yourself. We are not going to invent a ban rate for either path. We are going to say the paths are not the same, and their site currently describes both.

Karmy's default matches the manual half. The draft is yours to post, on the account you choose. The warm-up guide is how we think a new account should spend its first month if you are the one posting: value comments, links late, promotion rare. A karmito is coming soon. It is not a pack of accounts emailed after checkout.

Keywords find noise. Intent finds the buyer.

A keyword tool is honest about what it is. If the keyword is "espresso app," you will see people arguing about machines, posting photos, and occasionally asking what to use. ReplyGuy says their selection step keeps the high-quality recent ones where a shoutout fits. Good. The unit they bill, though, still starts at the mention. One credit to surface a comment. The incentive of a mention product is coverage.

Our bias is the opposite, and it is on the homepage in plainer words: a handful of threads a week where someone is already asking. Take the Brewlog example from how it works. The thread worth a draft is "my notes app failed me, what are you logging shots in?" The thread that is not worth a draft is a gear photo with the word espresso in the title. A keyword tracker will see both. A credit budget spent on both is how founders end up with a folder of clever replies and no one who was shopping.

The draft, when we send one, is supposed to answer first. Mention the product only where it is actually an answer, in the same breath as "I built this," and leave room for the other options. If the subreddit's rules forbid the mention, the draft should not include it. We read those rules before writing. You should still glance at the sidebar. Rules change, and a model does not get banned. You do.

When ReplyGuy is the better fit

Karmy is the better fit when Reddit is the channel, you are tired of keyword false positives, and you want the price to stay flat when a topic gets loud. Growth, at €19, covers up to five missions and the webhook. Scale, at €39, covers up to 20 missions. That is the team feature we actually ship. It is not an agency concierge.

A week, without the meter anxiety

You open Telegram. There are a few threads, not a few hundred keyword hits. You delete the sentence that sounds like a landing page. You post. You answer the person who replies, because early replies are how a comment stays visible, and a comment that stays visible is the only kind an assistant can stumble on later. On Scale, a weekly check of ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini. It is not a credit, and it is not a promise that ChatGPT will name you from Reddit. The weekly routine for Perplexity, Gemini and other AI answers is the AI answers playbook. The 3.83% to 0.52% drop is in the blog post.

If you were about to buy ReplyGuy only because the homepage says "sent," read the how-it-works page first. On Reddit, "sent" currently means you. On that point we are the same. The argument for switching is everything before the paste: which thread, why it is worth it, and a price that does not tick down while you decide.

ReplyGuy alternative: FAQ

Is Karmy a ReplyGuy alternative?

For Reddit commenting, yes. For Twitter auto-replies and web-wide keyword coverage, no. We do not try to be that product.

What does a ReplyGuy credit buy?

On their public pricing block: 1 credit for a comment they surface, 3 for a posted and verified reply, 5 for a DM fallback, 5 for a brand audit after the first free audit. Public monthly plans run from Pro at $49 (10 keywords, 100 credits, 1 project) to Agency at $499 (1,000 keywords, 5,000 credits).

Will ReplyGuy post on Reddit for me?

Their how-it-works page says you post it. Their FAQ says purchased Reddit accounts are emailed to you. Those are both on replyguy.com. Confirm with them. On Karmy, you post the draft. A karmito is coming soon.

What does Karmy cost?

Ten days free, no card, then €9 a month for one mission, €19 for up to five, or €39 on Scale for up to 20 missions. A karmito is coming soon.

What if I need both Reddit and X?

Use a tool that admits it does X. Do not stretch Karmy into a network we do not watch. Plenty of founders run Reddit properly and leave the other networks for later. That is a strategy, not a missing feature.

Related: AI answers playbook · vs ReddGrow · vs Brand24 · vs F5Bot · vs Linkeddit · Promote a SaaS on Reddit

Fewer mentions. Better threads.

Karmy pings you where a comment can actually help, with the draft ready. Free for 10 days, no card to start.

Join the waitlist →